How do various platforms that host animation (Netflix, Cartoon Network, Disney Channel and Nickelodeon) compare on how they treat animation?

The Overlord

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2002
Messages
6,155
How do the various platforms that host animation (Netflix, Cartoon Network, Disney Channel and Nickelodeon) compare in terms of how they treat animation?

I am going to rank Netflix on the top, not only have they made decent commitments to animated series like Voltron, She-Ra, Carmen Sandiego, etc but they also rescued projects like Castlevania and Klaus and supported some experimental projects like Love, Death + Robots. Also, the fact that they are the biggest streaming service running currently gives them an advantage over everyone else, kids today spend more time online over watching traditional TV is an advantage. They are not perfect though, they did screw over Tuca and Bertie and 12 Forever.

Second would be Cartoon Network, sure people complain about them over showing Teen Titans Go and in the PowerPuff Girls reboot sucks, but they gave big commitments to Steven Universe and Adventure Time, gave K.O Lets Be Heroes a decent run and has some interesting new stuff airing on the network.

Disney Channel/Disney XD comes in third, but it is a close second with Cartoon Network. Sure Cartoon Network airs animation all the time, while Disney Channel does not, but Disney has made interesting content recently, like Gravity Falls, also Duck Tales moved from Disney XD to Disney Channel. Star vs. The Forces of Evil had a disappointing ending but did get a solid commitment from Disney. They also have interesting new content on Disney Channel like Owl House and Amphibia. However, Disney should lose points on how it has made every Disney cartoon, besides Big Hero 6, since 2013.

Dead last is Nickelodeon/Nicktoons, which seems to have disdain towards animation. Nicktoons is treated as a graveyard for animation and perfectly good series are sent there to die (like Harvey Beaks, Welcome to the Wayne, Rise of the TMNT, etc.) Disney treats Disney XD better than Viacom treats Nicktoons. Really in the last decade, aside from Spongebob, what cartoons as it treated well, TMNT 2012 and The Loud House and its spin-offs? Really I think Glitch Tech is better off on Netflix over Nickelodeon.

Do you agree with my rankings or do you have a different opinion?
 
Last edited:

KeldeoKitty

Slacker Musketeer
Joined
Sep 9, 2018
Messages
1,425
Location
USA
I don’t know about Netflix and how they host animation but I definitely agree with the rank for the channels.

Most Cartoon Network originals are presented pretty well especially Adventure Time, they did a fantastic job presenting it early on. Most of their promos aren’t the best but are still unique. Disney Channel recently has done a brilliant job presenting some of their new cartoons as well.

So how Nickelodeon hosts animation? Sigh... Well let’s put it this way.
I remember seeing the early promos for Harvey Beaks and well they flat out sucked. They presented it like it’s just another generic comedy and failed to highlight what made the show so special. The promos reeked of “We don’t know what this is or what to do with it”. I’m sure other Nicktoons also got poor presentation. Nick puts way more effort in promoting and presenting ratings stunt specials for SpongeBob and their kidcoms than most new Nicktoons.
 

The Overlord

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2002
Messages
6,155
I don’t know about Netflix and how they host animation but I definitely agree with the rank for the channels.

Most Cartoon Network originals are presented pretty well especially Adventure Time, they did a fantastic job presenting it early on. Most of their promos aren’t the best but are still unique. Disney Channel recently has done a brilliant job presenting some of their new cartoons as well.

So how Nickelodeon hosts animation? Sigh... Well let’s put it this way.
I remember seeing the early promos for Harvey Beaks and well they flat out sucked. They presented it like it’s just another generic comedy and failed to highlight what made the show so special. The promos reeked of “We don’t know what this is or what to do with it”. I’m sure other Nicktoons also got poor presentation. Nick puts way more effort in promoting and presenting ratings stunt specials for SpongeBob and their kidcoms than most new Nicktoons.

Regarding Netflix, I think it is sparking an animation revival and that is getting rivals like Amazon to invest in animation:


It's not perfect, it relies on algorithms and shows could become lost in its library of content and it did screw over 2 animated shows: 12 Forever and Tuca and Bertie. But is hosting the most experimental animation out there.

Frankly I think a show like Glitch Tech is better off on Netflix than Nickelodeon.
 

Rainbowkid37

Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
74
Location
I'm Not Telling you!
What About Qubo, PBS, and Discovery Family?

Qubo Seems to Have More Variety With Classics Such as Madeline or Babar and, Modern Shows Such as Mike the Knight and Rainbow Ruby. (Though Some Shows Such as Jane and The Dragon and Being Ian are Commonly Mistreated)

PBS is Decent When it Comes to Treating Their Shows. Shows Such as Nature Cat, Molly of Denali and Xavier Riddle are Treated Nicely and Older Shows Such as Arthur, SciGirls and (Thankfully) Caillou are Often Mistreated.

and Discovery is WORSE THAN NICK FOR CRYING OUT LOUD! Because They Seem to Mistreat ALL Of Their Shows Except for My Little Pony. Hanizuki Was Removed In Favor for a 30 Minute Toy ad (Poples) and Bootleg Shimmer and Shine (Luna Petua Is That What It's Called?) MLP is Basically Discovery's TTG.
 

KeldeoKitty

Slacker Musketeer
Joined
Sep 9, 2018
Messages
1,425
Location
USA
What About Qubo, PBS, and Discovery Family?

Qubo Seems to Have More Variety With Classics Such as Madeline or Babar and, Modern Shows Such as Mike the Knight and Rainbow Ruby. (Though Some Shows Such as Jane and The Dragon and Being Ian are Commonly Mistreated)

PBS is Decent When it Comes to Treating Their Shows. Shows Such as Nature Cat, Molly of Denali and Xavier Riddle are Treated Nicely and Older Shows Such as Arthur, SciGirls and (Thankfully) Caillou are Often Mistreated.

and Discovery is WORSE THAN NICK FOR CRYING OUT LOUD! Because They Seem to Mistreat ALL Of Their Shows Except for My Little Pony. Hanizuki Was Removed In Favor for a 30 Minute Toy ad (Poples) and Bootleg Shimmer and Shine (Luna Petua Is That What It's Called?) MLP is Basically Discovery's TTG.

I don’t keep up with Qubo but it appears to be just an archive for various older shows they don’t really air new content. They do air imports but that’s it.

PBS Kids both on the PBS and 24/7 channels have a decent variety depending in your area and consistently put out new shows. They still have Arthur and Cyberchase but at least they don’t over rely on them.

Discovery Family is definitely worse than Nick. As MLP seems to be the only cartoon they care about, even though FIM ended it still gets plenty of reruns. The Hub started strong but after it rebranded it really went downhill. But while Hub/Discovery Family was pretty good for it’s first few years, Nick was consistently terrible for the entirety of the 2010’s.
 

Orange Mo

orangemo
Joined
Jun 11, 2016
Messages
1,492
Location
Los Angeles, California
How do the various platforms that host animation (Netflix, Cartoon Network, Disney Channel and Nickelodeon) compare in terms of how they treat animation?

I am going to rank Netflix on the top, not only have they made decent commitments to animated series like Voltron, She-Ra, Carmen Sandiego, etc but they also rescued projects like Castlevania and Klaus and supported some experimental projects like Love, Death + Robots. Also, the fact that they are the biggest streaming service running currently gives them an advantage over everyone else, kids today spend more time online over watching traditional TV is an advantage. They are not perfect though, they did screw over Tuca and Bertie and 12 Forever.

Second would be Cartoon Network, sure people complain about them over showing Teen Titans Go and in the PowerPuff Girls reboot sucks, but they gave big commitments to Steven Universe and Adventure Time, gave K.O Lets Be Heroes a decent run and has some interesting new stuff airing on the network.

Disney Channel/Disney XD comes in third, but it is a close second with Cartoon Network. Sure Cartoon Network airs animation all the time, while Disney Channel does not, but Disney has made interesting content recently, like Gravity Falls, also Duck Tales moved from Disney XD to Disney Channel. Star vs. The Forces of Evil had a disappointing ending but did get a solid commitment from Disney. They also have interesting new content on Disney Channel like Owl House and Amphibia. However, Disney should lose points on how it has made every Disney cartoon, besides Big Hero 6, since 2013.

Dead last is Nickelodeon/Nicktoons, which seems to have disdain towards animation. Nicktoons is treated as a graveyard for animation and perfectly good series are sent there to die (like Harvey Beaks, Welcome to the Wayne, Rise of the TMNT, etc.) Disney treats Disney XD better than Viacom treats Nicktoons. Really in the last decade, aside from Spongebob, what cartoons as it treated well, TMNT 2012 and The Loud House and its spin-offs? Really I think Glitch Tech is better off on Netflix over Nickelodeon.

Do you agree with my rankings or do you have a different opinion?

You forgot about Fox.
 

Streaker Prower

Active Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2021
Messages
615
Location
Charlton, MA
PBS is Decent When it Comes to Treating Their Shows. Shows Such as Nature Cat, Molly of Denali and Xavier Riddle are Treated Nicely and Older Shows Such as Arthur, SciGirls and (Thankfully) Caillou are Often Mistreated.
I like how both Nature Cat and Molly of Denali are treated very nice and renew both of them
 

JMTV

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2020
Messages
2,314
Location
Miramar, FL
I can't really answer that question since all of them were the same.

They treat their shows with love and attention, they treat their shows like crap. What's the difference?
 

The Overlord

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2002
Messages
6,155
I can't really answer that question since all of them were the same.

They treat their shows with love and attention, they treat their shows like crap. What's the difference?

Sure there is a difference, Netflix cancels a lot of stuff, but really how much animated stuff have they canceled? Most of the animated shows have had a good amount of seasons, with one big exception.

Also, Disney canceled Owl House, but they gave the creators 3 specials to finish up the story, meanwhile, Nick sent Its Pony to Nicktoons with no fanfare.
 

JMTV

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2020
Messages
2,314
Location
Miramar, FL
Sure there is a difference, Netflix cancels a lot of stuff, but really how much animated stuff have they canceled? Most of the animated shows have had a good amount of seasons, with one big exception.

Also, Disney canceled Owl House, but they gave the creators 3 specials to finish up the story, meanwhile, Nick sent Its Pony to Nicktoons with no fanfare.
Touché.
 

Spotlight

Staff online

Who's on Discord?

Latest profile posts

Tom Cruise Made His First Billion Dollar Movie!
Congrats to the Colorado Avalanche, my hockey team
Nickelodeon’s first foreign victim to Paramount+, and CN is the only one left in the country.

I didn't think she could do a higher pitched voice. Then again, I didn't think she could do a grandma voice, but she did.

With Nickelodeon celebrated Pride Day this year, they included Power Rangers Dino Fury episode, even though Nick already lost rights late last year.

Featured Posts

Top